July 23rd, 2007

Embedded metadata comes with its own challenges, especially for the inexperienced and the uninformed. From ars technica:

The book actually leaked out through the tubes last week as some enterprising soul took photographs of every single page of the book and made them available through BitTorrent […]

The EFF took a peek of its own at the leaked photos and did some cursory detective work. They found that the EXIF metadata attached to the photos contains the serial number of the camera used to take the pictures, along with all the other technical details about the settings used to make the image. That unique serial could be the leaker's undoing if Scholastic can find a way to link it up with an individual, and the EFF suggests that (perhaps) they can.

If the camera (a Canon Rebel) was registered with the company when first purchased, then Canon potentially has the information that Scholastic needs to make a bust. If this goes to court, expect Scholastic to go after such information.

It's little different than with search engines–unless we make conscious decisions otherwise, we leave little bits of ourselves behind whenever we do anything on the internet.

Comments
1
Loren - 3:49 pm 7/23/2007

Sounds like a good thing to me, Shelley.

And another reminder that if criminals weren't so stupid we'd never catch them.

Of course, I'd have used my scanner, not my Canon.

Which is not to say that I know whether or not my my scanner includes a serial number on the images it scans.

2

Hmmm … I use a Nikon and i took a look at the metadata and could not see any camera serial number. There was a unique id for each picture, does that ID contain the camera serial number?

Someday i hope to see the geo loaction of each photo in the metada. Then some smart browser could put a gadget on web pictures the clicking of which would go directly to map. That way i wouldn't need to put all those placemarks on my posts.

3
Doug Alder - 5:32 pm 7/23/2007

If it is a combination photocopier/scanner/printer all-in-one job Loren then it probably does. It's a security device that allows law enforcement to track down people who use their computer printers to print ransom/terrorist etc notes. Most manufacturers provide this now.

4
Bud Gibson - 8:54 pm 7/23/2007

So, what do you do in a world where nothing is secret anymore?

5
Shelley - 10:36 pm 7/23/2007

Loren, I don't support what the person did who copied the book online. I wonder at someone who would take so much time — they have nothing better to do than try to spoil people's fun?

I don't think they would get in much trouble. If they got sued for copyright violation, it would have to be proven in court that such copying harmed book sales. Hard to prove when the book sold more in a weekend than any other book, ever.

Don't know Seth, I've never looked in the EXIF for a serial number. I'll have to try that out with my software.

Doug, good to know before I send out all those love letters ;-)

Bud, when there are no secrets, then all is a secret.

6

and you don't have to ask canon about the serial number of the camera

ask flickr…….
(or google, or soon: semantic web search)

7

[…] me. But somebody. From ars technica, via Shelley Powers: [Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows] actually leaked out through the tubes last week as some […]

Thanks to all those who have contributed to the discussion. Comments are now closed, but you can contact the author of the post directly.