October 22nd, 2007

Leave it to the libraries to remind us of what's really important:

Several major research libraries have rebuffed offers from Google and Microsoft to scan their books into computer databases, saying they are put off by restrictions these companies want to place on the new digital collections.

Although Google is making public-domain books readily available to individuals who wish to download them, Mr. Kahle and others worry about the possible implications of having one company store and distribute so much public-domain content.

Scanning the great libraries is a wonderful idea, but if only one corporation controls access to this digital collection, we’ll have handed too much control to a private entity,” Mr. Kahle said.

The Open Content Alliance, he said, “is fundamentally different, coming from a community project to build joint collections that can be used by everyone in different ways.”

(emph. mine)

Several libraries are working with Google and the Open Content Alliance, but many more, such as the Boston Library, Smithsonian, Library of Congress, and Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution are going with the Open Alliance.

(via MetaFilter)

Comments
1
ralph - 8:28 pm 10/22/2007

Brewster Kahle is my hero.

2

On a related note, I'm starting to get cheesed off at Google Book Search's handling of feedback.

Without trying very hard I've identified a category of over 250k works that as far as I understand are in the public domain (subject to a trivial verification or quality check) but are viewable in their system with only limited preview or no preview at all.

I first communicated with them about this problem in January 2006. I've tried a few more times since, but all I get are brush-offs, or silence.

Thanks to all those who have contributed to the discussion. Comments are now closed, but you can contact the author of the post directly.