Categories
Legal, Laws, and Regs People Political

Don’t condemn the regular police in Chicago and Portland

Folks were upset when Illinois State Police showed up at an ICE protest in Chicago. Some questioned why Pritzker would do so. Were the state police now siding with ICE?

The answer to why the ISP showed up can be found in federal judge’s ruling about the federalization of Oregon National Guard in Portland. In her decision, in page after page, Judge Karin Immergut detailed what exactly is happening on the streets of Portland, and how any protest that crossed the line, no matter how minor, was met and handled by the local police, without any needed assist from any other party.

Judge Immergut wasn’t just stopping the seeming military takeover of our cities, she was also providing a guide in how cities and states can ensure that military incursions can be avoided: by having local and state police present at any ICE protest. Not only can the local police ensure that no laws are broken, their presence should also, hopefully, prevent some of egregious violence that federal police and ICE have been inflicting on law-abiding protestors.

In addition, local and state police can act as witness, providing a true recounting of events rather than that slop being fed to the press from DHS.

It’s also important for protests to stay peaceful and nonviolent. Even traditional nonviolent forms of civil disobedience, such as sitting in streets, should be avoided because there is nothing Trump, Noem, and their bully boys want more than to bash in liberal heads, and cry ‘assault’ when some protester’s face meets their fists.

These aren’t normal times. We cannot expect the federal government to act lawfully, or with anything resembling reasonable control. We have to assume in each and every incidence of protester meeting feds that the feds will unleash violence: pushing, shoving, shooting tear gas and non-lethal projectiles into any group of assembled people.

We want local and state police there…as long as they remember that the feds are not their brothers in arms: they are an invasion of people seeking to harm the people the local police have sworn to protect.

Categories
Environment People Savannah

International Paper is closing in Savannah. Good.

No community likes to lose jobs, and the 1100 jobs lost with International Paper closing two mills in the Savannah area is going to be painful.

But let’s stop pretending that International Paper has been a good neighbor, because this just isn’t true.

International Paper has been one of the largest industrial users of water in our area, and one of the largest drawing down on the Florida Aquifer. This, at a time when water use is becoming problematic in our community…if the recent boil water order Savannah suffered didn’t properly catch all of our attention.

According to an article in The Current in 2024, IP pulls 12 million gallons of water from the Floridan aquifer every single day. That’s 12 million gallons of water that could go to homes, rather than river water currently being utilized.

Why doesn’t IP use the river water? Because it costs money to treat this water, and why spend the money when the aquifer water is so accessible and so pristine? However, it is the nature of this water that makes it more ideal for human consumption.

“This region is growing,” said Ben Kirsch, legal director of the Ogeechee Riverkeeper. “There’s more people coming in, and those people are going to need water, and it’s a prioritization of how the aquifer is used. The aquifer needs very little treating. It’s pristine water, and we really think that it should be used for human uses, whether that’s for domestic supply or for agriculture.”

 

“We want to sustain the aquifer. We want to see it start to recover, and as you draw millions of gallons a day out of it. You’re not necessarily helping it. That’s not helping it recover.”

In addition, IP manages to also pollute the water it really doesn’t want to use.

International Paper Company faces nearly $28,000 in state fines for discharging wastewater with unacceptable levels of potential fecal material from its Port Wentworth mill into the Savannah River over a six-month period in 2023, according to an order made public by Georgia environmental officials Monday.

 

The penalty also would apply to the unauthorized release in December of nearly 185,000 gallons of partially treated wastewater into a storm drain and ultimately into the river, the Georgia Environmental Protection Division noted in the document.

Not just the water, IP also pollutes the air, as so many of us know when the wind runs from a certain direction.

In 2022, International Paper’s northwest Savannah mill released more than 367,000 metric tons of heat-trapping carbon dioxide, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency data shows. That’s 84% more than the county’s second-leading carbon polluter, the U.S. Sugar Savannah Refinery, and the equivalent of what nearly 83,000 gas-powered vehicles would emit over the course of a year, according to the EPA.

 

Carbon dioxide is the leading contributor to human-caused climate change.

 

International Paper’s Port Wentworth mill is fifth on the county’s list of greenhouse gas polluters. That facility emits more than 95,000 metric tons of carbon dioxide.

 

Combined, the two Chatham plants – with machinery powered by burning natural gas and wood – release the equivalent of carbon emissions generated in more than 1.2 million miles of travel by a typical vehicle with a combustion engine, according to EPA.

An interesting thing about that article I just linked: it’s about a taxpayer bond issue giving IP $130 million dollars to expand the plant.

A deal finalized with local officials this week positions Chatham County’s largest greenhouse gas polluter – and source of the city’s infamous sulfur smell – to significantly increase production at its Savannah-area facilities.

 

The Savannah Economic Development Authority (SEDA) on Tuesday approved issuing $130 million in bonds to “finance the costs of certain machinery, equipment and other personal property” at International Paper Company’s Savannah and Port Wentworth mills.

 

The Chatham County Board of Commissioners signed off on the deal late last year.

Of course, this all happened before IP decided to close down the Savannah-area plants in favor of a new plant in Alabama, where it will likely face less pesky oversight than in Georgia. And I’m sure the local area there offered even better deals than a measly $130 million dollars.

No one wants to hear of people losing jobs. Though it helps to know that unemployment is very low in our area, and we have a robust economy with multiple major employers, it’s difficult for people who have worked for the same company for decades to transition to another employer.

At the same time, though, it’s disingenuous to indulge in maudlin reminisces of the history of a company who basically can’t wait to kick the dirt of coastal Georgia from its shoes. IP likely knew that they would be closing these mills long before the announcement. Not providing more notice to its employees is the mark of a large, soulless corporation, not a small town hero.

Good-bye, good riddance, and now let’s worry about the people.

Update: Savannah Agenda has a good piece on the bond mentioned earlier.

Categories
Government People

Dear Buddy Carter: Do you believe in the rule of law?

Buddy, I have a question for you:

Do you believe in the rule of law?

I ask this question because we elected you to Congress to be our representative among Congressional lawmakers. That’s what Congress is, you know: lawmakers.

Yet in the few months since Trump has been in office, he and his cohort have been breaking existing laws to a degree never before seen in our country.

He has grabbed people off the street and sent them to a prison known for its enslavement and torture. He has cancelled grants to universities solely because they won’t let him control every last aspect of their operation. He has terminated student visas because they have written opinion pieces in newspapers he doesn’t like.

Trump has turned the Department of Justice into a revenge machine, telling it to open investigations on people who have done nothing more than deny his lie that he won the election in 2020.

He has sent people into agencies and they have openly broken security laws, including grabbing data they have no need for or legal reason to have. And when someone has exposed this behavior to you, in Congress, his life was threatened.

If a law firm has defended someone Trump doesn’t like, he has threatened them with dire consequences if they don’t adhere to his demands, all of which blatantly violate the Constitution.

He has gone after universities and threatened them—threatened them!— if the universities don’t give up their freedom of speech, and their own ability to govern themselves. And when Harvard bravely said no, all grants to the university were pulled—even though these grants were for research that help us live better and longer.

Trump has frozen funds that the country has guaranteed, both to agencies overseas and to our own domestic organizations and states. Funds that are necessary for medical care and medical research; to monitor storms and recover from them; to help communities better prepare for storms and other catastrophes; to help schools better serve their students and ensure all of the students are fed and educated equally; to support small businesses and farmers; to help the hungry, the sick, and those harmed by circumstances beyond their control.

Funds that you, in Congress, allocated and control. Supposedly control.

He openly and laughingly mocks our judicial system, and I include the Supreme Court in this, though this higher court’s timid responses to Trump’s outrageous acts have not shown it in at its best. But even when they finally pushed back, ever so slightly, he laughed at it. Not only laughed at it, he was joined by one of South America’s most brutal dictators in that laughter. His new best friend.

Now, he threatens to not only send migrants to a brutal life in another country, he threatens to send citizens, too. And we already know he’ll do so without giving anyone the benefit of legal representation in a court of law.

He’ll just send armed thugs into the street, dressed in plain clothes and wearing hoods and driving in black SUVs to grab people off the street and put them on a plane and then hold up his hands and go, “Oopsie! Made a mistake! Well, can’t do anything about it now, they’re in foreign control!”

We were warned that we were approaching a Constitutional crises, when the President of the United States held himself above the laws of the land. We waited in hope, and some fear, to see what he would do when courts intervened.

We now know what he’ll do: disobey the courts. We are no longer approaching a Constitutional crises, we’re in one, and we now wonder if, at the end of four years, will we even have a country left? Will we even be allowed to vote for who we want? Or will we receive notes pasted on our doors, threatening us if we don’t do as Trump asks?

And in all of this—all of it!—not one peep from you. Not one mild expression of concern. Not even a single, “well, we might want to reconsider this.” No, all you have done is appear on radically right newscasts as a way of pretending you don’t need a Town Hall, and then spent the time praising Trump.

So I ask you now, do you believe in the rule of law? You are our elected representative to Congress, to the body of lawmakers that have kept our country free, safe, and secure for 250 years. And as a lawmaker, isn’t it your sworn duty to ensure that laws are kept and not broken? Or is your allegiance to Trump so strong that you don’t care about the laws, or the harm that will come to the people in your district because these laws are broken? All that matters to you is Trump?

It’s a simple question, Buddy: Do you believe in the rule of law?

Sources

Who is Kilmar Abrego Garcia, the man ICE mistakenly deported to an El Salvador prison?

Trump officials cut billions in Harvard funds after university defies demands

How the Education Department cuts could hurt low-income and rural schools

Trump directs DOJ to investigate former administration officials who criticized him

USDA cancels $1 billion in funding for schools and food banks to buy food from local suppliers

FEMA cuts $30 million grant earmarked to improve flooding, drainage issues in Savannah

Public libraries in Georgia brace for federal cuts

Academic medical centers say funding cuts jeopardize health research

A whistleblower’s disclosure details how DOGE may have taken sensitive labor data

Video shows Tufts graduate student grabbed off the street by federal immigration officials

Core Democratic groups are preparing to be targeted by the Trump administration

The Trump administration’s defiance is proving Justice Sotomayor’s point

Lawrence on Trump attacking the rule of law: We are all Harvard. We are all Abrego Garcia.

Buddy Carter is Georgia’s First Congressional District Representative

 

 

 

Categories
Government People Political

Dear Buddy Carter

I was going to write to ask if you support the rule of law, but I was sidetracked by your latest newsletter. I was also going to write that appearing on ultra-conservative podcasts and radio shows and a carefully staged tele-town hall will not take the place a live town hall, but then I read your newsletter’s heading:

We’ve got your six

Evidently, you found one person who is willing to come out and talk about Biden being awful to vets, and no worries, Trump and Doug Collins will be there for the veterans. That’s what “we’ve got your six” implies.

In reality, though, Musk, Trump, and Collins’ actions have been particularly devastating to veterans. First of all, there’s the plan to cut 80,000 VA jobs. Most of these jobs will be health workers, and all of these cuts will have massive impact on what healthcare the VA can provide to veterans.

In addition, you are aware that up to 30% of government jobs are held by veterans, aren’t you? And that many of these veterans are disabled? So all that job cutting that Musk brags about comes with a heavy price for those who served in the military. Not only are they losing their access to good healthcare, they’re losing their jobs, too.

Why? Well, it seems as if most of this ‘cost cutting’ is to cram through a tax cut that primarily helps people like you, and Musk, and Trump. You know…rich people. And this tax cut will add a massive $37 trillion dollars to the national debt. That’s 37 with a whole bunch of zeros behind it. Darn, son, that’s a lot of money!

So, to make this seem less overwhelming, you all pretend there’s a lot of waste and fraud in government and you’re shutting down programs that help the less fortunate and firing good government employees who are just doing the job they were hired for and pretending *you’re making it all more efficient…when what’s really happening is you’re all making a huge mess and among those most particularly hurt are the veterans.

Cuts to VA healthcare, to the Veterans Crisis Line, increasing veteran unemployment…stop me when you get to the part where Collins and the rest of you are ‘helping veterans’. What’s worse is that cuts to other agencies will also hurt veterans: cuts to USDA funding for food banks and schools and to help small farmers, cuts to Medicaid, cuts to SNAP, cuts to Social Security—all of these will, in one way or another, hurt veterans.

And the hurt will pile up. What we’re seeing now in the few town halls Republicans have had will be nothing compared to what will happen in a couple of years when all this slash and burn of the federal government really starts to kick in. And trying to bring up Biden as the cause of all of it just won’t play to the crowd at that time. Most folks really aren’t that stupid.

No wonder you’re afraid to have a town hall. But you go ahead parading that one person who says Biden let the veterans down. I’m sure that veterans in your district will be interested in hearing what you have to say as they file for unemployment and try to get in to see a doctor. But I’d go light on the “we’ve got your six” claim, if I were you.

*I say “you’re” because you’re part of this. You’re a member of Congress and Congress has the power to tell the administration to stop what it’s doing, but instead, you’re just telling Trump and Musk to go right ahead…any destruction they do is fine by you.

5 reasons federal cuts are hitting veterans especially hard

Fired Veterans Call Widespread Trump and Musk Federal Job Cuts a Betrayal of Their Service

For Veterans Fired by Trump, the Sense of Betrayal Runs Deep

Trump adviser Alina Habba says veterans fired by DOGE are perhaps ‘not fit to have a job at this moment’

Veterans becoming face of Trump’s government cuts and Democrats’ resistance

CBO: Extending 2017 tax cuts could add $37 trillion in debt

New report shows that extending Trump’s tax cuts for the rich and corporations will hurt working families

Categories
People Political

Dear Buddy Carter

Your constituents want to hear from you.

Out on Nextdoor, I counted two separate change.org petition campaigns demanding that you have a live town hall. Folks in Tybee are getting together a group request for the same. I imagine if I looked further out, I’d find similar efforts up and down the coast.

Your constituents really want to hear from you.

Your March ‘tele-town hall’ is leaving most folks cold, if comments to your Facebook post on this are any indication. The voters want a chance to talk to you, face-to-face. They want you to hear from them, not just us passively hearing from you with your little PR newsletters extolling the virtues of a Musk-dominated White House.

True, you won’t be getting a warm reception. Folks are unhappy. They’re unhappy about cuts to federal programs they need. They’re not happy about closing down NOAA operations, or local Social Security offices, or firing veterans. It wasn’t until the DOGE-inspired cuts that most people realized that 30% of federal workers are veterans.

Most of your constituents don’t like Elon Musk. They don’t like the fact that this unelected billionaire is calling Social Security a ponzi scheme and broadly hinting about large cuts to the program under the guise of ‘fraud’. They don’t like seeing critical and necessary jobs being eliminated, only to scramble to re-hire the folks because the people doing the cuts have no clue about how the government works.

Instead of fixing the economy and lowering the price of eggs, folks are now being warned that we might go into a recession, but that’s OK: it’s for the greater good. But the only greater good that we see happening is a lot of filthy rich people are getting even richer, while the rest of us wonder if we’re actually going to continue getting our Social Security checks.

If what Trump and Musk are doing are so great, why won’t you defend their actions in person? Why are you so afraid to meet the voters face-to-face?

You don’t have a lot of options, Buddy. A town hall now, or the voters in two years.

If you think the chaos that is surrounding the DOGE actions now is going to get better, it won’t. We’re only now starting to see the damage the uncontrolled DOGE cuts have on government services. In a year, we could be looking at an unprecedented level of government failure because there just aren’t enough people around to keep things running. The first or third or fifth hurricane, the latest wildfire, an explosive growth of both measles and bird flu, failures in our food safety systems…something is going to hit the fan, and it won’t be something pleasant.

People will literally be dying.

And then there’s the very real possibility of enough systems failing that Social Security checks won’t be mailed, or Medicare payments won’t be made to doctors, or soldiers paid, or hard-hit areas getting emergency funds, and at that point, it will be too late to try and get your talking points across to the people.

Your only hope is to have a live town hall now, while you still can. And actually listen to the people. Listen to why they’re angry. They won’t be Democratic operatives hired to harass you, they will be folks that have voted for you in the past. Voted for you, but not for Musk. They didn’t vote for DOGE and they don’t like what’s happening. It doesn’t take a genius to see Trump’s little Musk experiment is failing, and failing badly.

And it doesn’t take a genius to see that Congress is doing little to stop any of it.

You can choose to live in a DC bubble and pretend real folk aren’t being hurt, while you carefully stage a tele-town hall with canned questions by pre-selected ‘voters’.  Or you could meet your voters on our terms and just maybe salvage your political career.

The choice is yours.