Categories
Specs

Too late solutions

Recovered from the Wayback Machine.

Flash at 6: Google calls Dave Winer. Ooo. The suspense.

Per Sam Ruby:

Robert Sayre: I noticed that the links his comment form have an interesting rel attribute.

Implemented. Prediction: that wouldn’t solve the problem.

I agree with Sam — this isn’t going to solve the problem. Gas station cash registers have signs saying that the attendants only keep 20.00 in cash on hand, but they’re still robbed.

Still, I remember something like this being discussed before.

Waiting for more. I love surprises.

Categories
Technology Weblogging

Take your hands off the tech and back away slowly

Recovered from the Wayback Machine.

Several people have linked to Martin Schwimmer and his indignation about the fact that Bloglines re-prints the content of his post, without attribution and with the possibility of future advertisements (…or guilty until proven innocent). This violates the cc license, he says, because he can only be republished if proper attribution is given, and in a non-commercial setting.

This sounded familiar, and sure enough, digging around in my archives finds this. where another person reacted in outrage when they found out their feed was being re-published:

What was a surprise is that Mitch reversed himself and now offers a Creative Commons license on his material, though the license information isn’t duplicated in Mitch’s RSS feed directly. Mitch also brings up the ‘commercial’ aspect of re-publishing the material at LiveJournal, and what’s to stop someone from grabbing the content and putting it behind password protected sites that charge money for access.

Easy – don’t publish all your entire post in your RSS feed; keep the RSS feeds to excerpts only. Remove the content-encoded field and just leave the description. And adjust your blogging tool to publish excerpts, only. If your weblogging tool doesn’t allow this adjustment, ask the tool builder to provide this capability. The RSS feeds are there to help promote your ideas, not promote their theft. But you have to control the technology, not let the technology control you.

Wait until he discovers the other online sites, such as 2rss.com, that do add ads into the feed if you use it to subscribe within any aggregator, Bloglines or not.

update

Also, see this about creative commons licenses and RSS feeds back in 2002.

Question to Mr. Schwimmer — is your cc license attached to your feed?

Categories
History Photography Places

Shaw’s Garden

When the balance sheet for 1839 was struck it showed, to the great surprise of Mr. Shaw, a net gain for the year of $25,000. He could not believe his own figures, and so went over them again and again until he could no longer doubt the fact. Telling the story many years afterward he said it seemed to him then that “this was more money than any man in my circumstances ought to make in a single year,” and he resolved then and there to go out of active business at the first good opportunity. The opportunity presented itself very early in the following year, and was promptly improved by the sale of his entire stock of merchandise. So at forty years of age – only the noon of life – with all his physical and mental powers unimpaired and vigorous, Henry Shaw was a free man – and the possessor of $250,000 with which to enjoy that freedom….

There is every reason to believe that, with his exceptional qualifications for success in this department, he might easily have increased the $250,000 to $2,500,000 long before he had reached the age of sixty. He retired, not because he was afraid of losing what he had made, or thought he could not make any more; but because he felt he had enough, and intended to enjoy it. He always owned his money; his money never owned him.

Yesterday was cold and clear with a nice dusting of sparkly white snow on the ground; perfect conditions for visiting the Botanical Gardens.

During the winter, especially when it’s cold, the Gardens rarely has visitors during the work week. However, being a public facility, it also has to keep its paths clear and dry, which makes it a wonderful place to walk after a snow. I find the Gardens a good place to walk when I want to have a quiet time to think about things, because unlike many of the Ozark trails, I don’t have to keep my mind on the paths.

I passed two couples and a single walker yesterday but other than that had the place to myself. Even the koi had retreated to warmer climes, rather than follow me as I traversed the zig-zagged board walk. The previous days snow had built up on the bushes, and then slightly melted due to the warmer conditions. However, there was a sudden temperature drop, which then froze the snow on the plants, leaving everything coated with just enough snow to look like it was dropped on by a mad cake maker with the mother of all bowls of icing.

I always head to the Japanese Gardens when I enter the park, no matter the season. Some of the water fountains were frozen and shut down, but the water in the lake and streams circulates enough to keep them liquid. What was rather interesting to look at was the snow that had been blown around the raked gravel in the gardens, looking more like lint caught on bit of rough than what it was.

Each time I visit the Gardens, I always try and walk down a new path or explore a new corner. Yesterday I visited the Henry Shaw Mausoleum: a red brick and stained glass octagonel building surrounded by plants, and containing Shaw’s tomb and a beautiful white marble effigy. It was a bit hard to see in through the iron gated windows but I managed, and even got a fairly decent photo showing both the effigy and some of the stained glass.

Shaw effigy in marble

After seeing the effigy, I got curious about Henry Shaw, the man behind the Gardens, and when I got home looked him up. I found an annotated history of the Gardens, including several excellent photos from the 1860’s until the 1920’s. It was in this that I found the earlier quote about Shaw, made by a friend of his, as well the following photo, which was taken of him as he posed for his effigy.

The photos in the history were digitalized through a program funded by the State of Missouri library system, which leads the country when it comes to actively seeking out and putting digitalized multimedia material on the web for public access. Being the magpie that I am, I immediately became distracted by this new virtual piece of fluff and searched around to see what else was online through this program.

I struck gold when I found the site, Voices of World War II: Experiences at the Front and at Home containing photos, radio transcripts, music, and even video of the bombing of Pearl Harbor. This multimedia immersion into history is the richest I’ve been able to find on World War II, and listening to many of the radio broadcasts last night, I was surprised again and again, how the experiences of the events of the time differ from our historical perspective of same. for instance, a radio broadcast by H.V. Kaltenborg one week after Pearl Harbor showed that interest was stronger in fighting Germany, who had not fired one shot against the US, than in Japan. “If we can defeat Hitler,” Kaltenborg claimed, “we can defeat Japan almost in our leisure”–a piece of arrogance we were to pay for time and again in the war.

The site contains complete songs from the era, and even photos of the records themselves. Remember Abbott and Costello’s baseball routine? You’ll be able to hear wartime quasi-classics such as the Murphy Sisters, “You’re a Sap Mr. Jap” and the odd, surreal, When the Atom Bomb Fell by Karl and Harty in addition to more popularly known Glenn Miller music.

Among all the interviews with combatants, and recordings of actual fighting, it is still the broadcasts from the radio men of the time that had the most appeal to me, including some from one of my favorite journalists, Edward R. Murrow. This is radio, at its best and brightest.

To return to my original explorations of Botanical Gardens and Henry Shaw, it’s not just the history of the place that has forever found a home on the web–the Gardens’ famous collection of rare herbal books that Shaw purchased from another collection has also been digitalized. If you’re interested in botany or gardening or herbs; love looking through exquisitely detailed pen and ink or watercolor images of plants, as well as the finest copperplate; or have an interest in bookbinding, click here, and then be prepared to lose hours of time. I love to photograph plants and trees out on my walks, but will be the first to admit that the effort falls short in comparison. Not that I’ll stop.

After pulling myself way from the distractions of multimedia, I continued to reading Shaw’s bio. Most writings of Shaw are positive, and by all accounts, he was a kind and generous person. He never married, and once was even sued for breach of promise, but the case ended up being dismissed. Good thing, too, as it would have taken enough money to disrupt his dream of creating one of the finest gardens in the country.

Still there is a shadow among the bright flowers in Shaw’s history. Being English by birth, when he first moved to St. Louis he was against slavery; years later, however, he was the owner of eleven slaves, most likely purchased to work on the Gardens. Three of his slaves, a mother and two children, tried to run away, helped by a free black woman, Mary Metchum; they were caught on the Illinois side of the river, and Methum was subsequently tried, but nothing further is known about what happened to her. As for the slaves, he sold the mother, but there’s no record about what happened with the children.

Historians like to point out that years later, after the civil war, he was one of the few employers in the area who would employ the people referred to as ‘Bohemians’: newly freed black people who had a difficult time finding work in this former slave state. One such black ended up becoming his personal assistant until his death, though I’m not sure if it’s the black man depicted in the following photograph.

Anyone who has walked the Gardens can’t deny the benefit of Shaw’s vision for a grand garden — it is a wonderous place; one of the finest of its kind in the world, and an important component of in the education system in this state. However, his image as a ‘great humanitarian’ must be forever tarnished by the ills of owning another human being.

The reality of human failing aside, I still find Shaw’s marble effigy to be beautiful amid the stained glass and red brick, trees, and flowers. Especially the flowers. After all, flowers are blind to the color of man.

Categories
Technology

Be Stingy

Regarding Dave Winer’s idea for some form of centralized syndication feed system, I got a chuckle out of the comment, “What problem am I having and how is a centralized service going to help?” in Phil Ringalda’s post Centralized Subscription? Not that way thanks. You see now the great benefit of being exposed to us techs through weblogging: you get to experience, with us, the joy of uncertainty that comes from knowing that you’re always on the edge of failure.

Dave does have a point in that if you provide one click subscriptions for one aggregator, such as a Subscribe via Bloglines button, it won’t work for other aggregators; you either have to blow off the others, or you end up with a trail of buttons down your page, like stepping stones across a vast sea of syndication.

You could be like me, and provide the bare minimum to aid in subscription: auto-discovery enabled via my weblog tool, and a couple of links to feeds in my sidebar. However, I will be the first to admit that clicking a link to open an XML file isn’t the friendliest way to get people to subscribe to your site’s syndication feeds.

I am open to alternatives to this arrangement, but not necessarily Dave’s approach. Though he hastens to say that his approach isn’t a centralized directory, it is a centralized source of data, one with consequences beyond the intended purpose.

Dave’s solution would require that you pass to the service a link to an OPML file, which contains a listing of sites to which you subscribe, and then click a link to add a new subscription. In return the service would provide the list in a format specific to whatever aggregator you use. Your subscription list would then be merged with other subscription lists, and made public; the data contained being accessible for other purposes.

With this approach, not only would I be able to more easily subscribe to your writing, I could also take a look at who you read, and don’t read. Would your subscription list be the same as your blogroll? If not, are you prepared to answer questions from those who you link to, but don’t read? How about those who you read, but don’t link? I could even use your subscription list as my own, so that I can read the exact same sites you read every day; more, I could follow you around in comments, adding my own following yours, just to let you know I’m near and thinking of you.

Phil wrote his own scenario, about subscribing to a site that provides information about spastic colons, which can then get Googled by the hot new love of your life. We say we’re an open book, but do we really want to be that open?

As Phil demonstrates so effectively, which service works best is the one that requires the minimum of information. This follows from a known paradigm in designing relational databases or class systems in languages such as PHP–more data is more overhead and increased complexity, so you keep the data needs as simple and specific to the problem being solved, as possible.

In fact, though the needs of aggregation aren’t the same as identity, we could apply Kim Cameron’s second law of identity, the Law of Minimal Disclosure, to this problem: The solution which discloses the least identifying information is the most stable, long-term solution.

In the case of too many subscription buttons, Phil recommends the Syndication Subscription Service, as a solution. The service doesn’t require anything more than a link to your syndication feed, and when accessed, returns a set of buttons for many different aggregators. In fact, I liked this service so much that I’ve pulled my links to my two Atom and RDF feeds in the sidebar and replaced them with a link to it, instead.

Though it is also a centralized service, it’s one that requires a minimum of data and effort, and since the code to support it is open source, could be duplicated if need be. Best of all, it’s something I can use now for this newly discovered problem I didn’t know I had, but which has now been solved, and so no longer exists.

Much of the discussion is about handling feeds like audio files, and the so-called feed protocol. I like what Seth Dillingham wrote on this long ago:

The feed protocol was originally designed for farms. Cattle, for example, just have to click a button to access a feed: url on the farmer’s server, which causes grain to be dropped in the trough.

In a bizarre misuse of this important technology, the feed protocol can also be used to request an RSS or Atom file, to “feed your brain.”

I’m with the cows on this one — if I can’t poke a button with my nose and have it give me food right now, I’m moving to a different barn.

Categories
Weather

From summer to winter in hours

It’s hard to believe looking at this photo that a scant 12 hours before, the temperature was in the 70’s and I was out walking in my t-shirt, driving with the windows down. We went from windy, warm, and wet to a very wet and strong thunderstorm last night, which turned into a snow storm at mid-day. The Meramec, which had been falling is now rising again. And this is our dry season.

Luckily, the odd weather pattern we’ve been experiencing is supposedly over, and we should be looking at a relatively normal winter from this point on. Though it may seem nice to have such temperate conditions, it’s hard to adjust to the weather when it changes so quickly: one day freezing, the next day spring warm, with the barometer rising and falling with each cycle.

Of course, those who have been buried under four feet of snow for the last two months are probably less than sympathetic to my complaints.